Black Mothers are Raising Awareness for Safer Births in Texas

Alexis Castelli plays with her son, Zakari Armstrong, Sunday, April 24 at Pflugerville lake park located at 18216 Weiss Ln, Pflugerville, TX. Photo credit: Timia Cobb

By: Timia Cobb

Email: Mimilovemia@gmail.com

For many, pregnancy is a time for joy, learning about how to be loving parents and growing families. But for Black mothers it has become a stressful nine months of wondering if they could die during their pregnancy due to racism and medical disparities.

The moment Alexis Castelli, 20, of Round Rock, learned she was pregnant, she was hesitant to give birth in a hospital. To combat the hesitancy, she researched birthing centers and different OBGYNs in the area, trying to find the safest option for not only her but the baby boy she was carrying.

30 weeks into her pregnancy Castelli had a doula who she trusted and would be delivering at OBGYN North in Austin, but prior health conditions prevented this. Castelli found herself stressed and unable to breathe. Castelli was asthmatic, but her pregnancy had worsened her asthma attacks.

“I was just having a really hard time,” Castelli said. “I was doing a lot of walking around, being in school, so I was having a really hard time breathing.”

Unable to ease the tightness in her chest and the concern in her heart, Castelli decided to visit her OBGYN office, who never gave her the help she needed. Castelli arrived at the hospital at 4:30 p.m. and did not receive a breathing treatment till 9:45 p.m. that night.

“I was just in so much disbelief, but I didn't really know where else to go, “Castelli said. “So, I just stayed and hoped that they would help me, and I just was getting so frustrated. At that point I was just crying, and I couldn't even get words out because I just cannot believe that at this point, we had been there for four hours, and I had still gotten no breathing treatment and no help.”

During her wait, Castelli said she was ignored and felt hopeless due to no one coming to her assistance, at one point her partner had to find a nurse to ask if anyone would be available to see Castelli after waiting for hours.

Alexis Castelli holds her son, Zakari Armstrong while caressing her baby bump, Sunday, April 24 at Pflugerville lake park located at 18216 Weiss Ln, Pflugerville, TX. Photo credit: Timia Cobb

“I called the nurse so many times and I keep hearing her go to these other rooms that are pressing their buttons after me and I'm getting so frustrated because I can look around there's no Black staff, there's not even a brown person like everybody's white,” Castelli said. “I’m like nobody is seeing me. All these other ladies in these other rooms are white and why are they getting help? I'm sitting here, been telling them that I've been having trouble breathing for this amount of time and they're just so nonchalant about it, just whatever, just brushed me off.”

After that night, Castelli knew a hospital would not be the place she would be giving birth and took the security of her pregnancy into her own hands.

“Basically, I was like I refuse to birth at this place, “Castelli said. “I was like, I don't care if we have just the three of us and have an unassisted home birth somewhat like, you know, she would just be there helping us but I was like I'm not doing it at a hospital., we can’t do the birthing center, we have like little no options left.”

Texas has among the highest maternal mortality rates in the nation. Black mothers are now taking action to assure Black maternal mortality doesn’t become another unbeatable high percentage by addressing racism Black mothers face during pregnancy and educating expecting mothers on the importance of pre-pregnancy health care.

 

In 2018, Texas accumulated 70 maternal mortalities, the highest amongst any other state. Maternal mortality occurs when a mother dies because of pregnancy-related reasons, during labor, or within 42 days after childbirth.

According to research conducted by the CDC in 2018, the biggest victim of maternal mortality is non-Hispanic Black women. In a state where pregnancy could lead to death, Black mothers choose to protect themselves by relying on Black doctors, doulas and spreading awareness to fellow Black women.

Despite Black Texans being a racial minority, they accumulate the majority of health issues in the state. According to the Altarum's Economic Impacts Of Health Disparities In Texas 2020 Report, Black citizens experience death from diabetes, cancer and cardiovascular diseases at higher percentages than white and Hispanic Texans in 2020.

Black mothers are stepping up to assure Black women are given safe births and given the resources they need to protect themselves and their families from dying during and after pregnancy.

Causes behind the deaths

According to Dr. Carla Ortique, Texas Maternal Mortality and Morbidity Review Committee Vice-Chair and Subcommittee Chair, Black women are encountering two prominent issues during pregnancy, racism and lack of prior health conditions.

“In our country, people of color have been discriminated against, Black people in particular and so absolutely, that has a detrimental impact on health,” Ortique said. “But it's not as simple as saying, well, we need to find a provider that's not racist.”

The Texas Maternal Mortality and Morbidity Review Committee was formed in 2011, with Dr. Ortique being an original member of the committee. The committee recommends areas of improvement for better methods of practice for hospitals. Rather than enforcing, the committee highly encourages hospitals to follow the recommendations.

“We basically review the deaths of women that occur in our state during pregnancy and up to one year beyond,” Ortique said. “So, looking at maternal deaths, and attempting to identify causes, contributing factors whether or not they're preventable, and then to develop recommendations when they are found to be pregnancy-related, and preventable.”

The CDC states Texas is above the national average birth maternal morbidity rates, and Black women still experience higher birth mortality rates than others.

“The [Black women] have a two to three times higher risk of mortality,” Ortqiue said.

Dr. Carla Ortique, Obstetrics & Gynecology, Texas maternal mortality and morbidity Review Committee Vice-Chair and Subcommittee Chair. Photo credit: Dr. Ortique

 

On Dec. 6, 2019, TMMMRC Subcommittee on Maternal Health Disparities found that “factors related to the provider and facility were the most frequently identified contributors to pregnancy-related deaths among Non-Hispanic Black women,” meaning the facilities and people Black women go to for help during pregnancy are also the ones having a hand in their death.

“We've developed a subcommittee to look at maternal health disparities and to help guide the review process to make sure that a health equity lens is being applied to the review process and to make sure that recommendations are developed that would address institutional and societal level drivers of maternal health inequities,” Ortique said.

 

Pregnancy-related high blood pressure disorders are the leading causes for death for Black mothers. However, many blood pressure disorders are preventive if given the amount of time and knowledge, which Dr. Amy Raines-Milenkov, Assistant Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at University of North Texas Health Science Center, said this isn't always the case.

 

“As far as health status of women going into pregnancies [can be] an issue, but we also know that women, well the Black population in general face more discrimination and in the healthcare system itself,” Raines-Milenkov said. “So, when we think about, like delays in recognizing health conditions or dangerous situations during birth, immediately following birth, that's when kind of discrimination comes into play.”

In 2020, four million Black households were single parent oriented. Having to go through pregnancy alone, not receiving proper health care till pregnancy, along with the Superwoman Schema Black women have, all contribute to a risker pregnancy.

Black women in society have the pre-assumed image of being strong, which they also adopt themselves, this is called the Superwoman Schema or the superwoman complex. This way of thinking and taking on more stress as a working woman, head of household and in a majority of other roles forces Black women to accept many levels of stress without addressing the emotional and health damages it does to them.

“There’s still this idea of Black women having so much the cumulative stress on their body, from being, like even in situations where [they’re] high achieving women, high incomes, but that doesn't protect you necessarily from a life of discrimination, and having to work really hard,” Raines-Milenkov said.

Dr. Amy Raines-Milenkov, Assistant Professor of Obstetrics and Gynecology at University of North Texas Health Science Center. Photo credit: Dr. Raines-Milenkov

The Superwoman Schema causing Black women stress and medical issues, along with racism in hospitals is the reason why despite education or financial level, all Black women can experience the same health concerns during pregnancy.

“We know with Black women it doesn't matter, it’s not a poverty issue, it doesn't matter if you have insurance or not, you're still more likely to die,” Raines-Milenkov said.

Mothers stopping mortalities

Committed to having a homebirth, Castelli enlisted the help of BlackHomebirths Matter ATX, one of the many assistant birthing organizations in Texas. The organization is run by a group of BIPOC midwives in Austin who help minority women have safe home deliveries and give donations through a birthing fund, dedicated to decreasing out-of-pocket costs for expecting parents wanting a midwife and home birth.

“I was actually able to get 3000 out of the 4000 we needed from the birth fund which was super awesome,” Castelli said. “We found our midwife who was the other midwife who runs the birth fund, who was awesome, amazing and we started care at 31 weeks with her and started planning for this home birth.”

Throughout Texas, various organizations are blooming to cater to the needs of Black mothers due to the increased risk they encounter during pregnancy.

 

Black MamasATX is one of the many Texan labor and pregnancy support organizations started in the past few years. Black Mamas ATX was founded in 2018 by Professor Michele Roundtree in the School of Social Work at UT Austin. Rountree took action after witnessing the rates at which Black women were experiencing pregnancy-related mortalities.

 The organization is Black-led and staffed. Black Mamas ATX helps mothers by holding a “sister circle” each month where expecting mothers or post-pregnancy mothers can come together to discuss childbirth concerns before and after labor. Black MamaATX also provides free doula and social work services to Black mothers.

Erin Backus, Black MamasATX Grant Manager, joined the organization as an intern but was drawn to Black Mama ATX due to their cause and concern for helping mothers have comfortable pregnancies.  

“My sister, my best friend, were having kids around this time, and all this stuff that I was learning about you know, these outcomes, they were experiencing them,” Backus said. “Thank God they survived, but I just thought, you know, it sucks that they had to endure this.”

Since its founding, Black MamasATX has helped 130 mothers have successful pregnancies, organized the Show Up for Black Mothers which raises public awareness of racism Black mothers experience and invested in the work of multiple Black physicians, nurses, hospital administrators, doulas, midwives, and social workers to create an available healthcare network.

“We have employed doulas and pay for their training,” Backus said. “And so, these are Black women who live in Austin, who serve other Black pregnant women. They attended births, they attended prenatal visits, they give childbirth education and lactation support. They provide a lot of emotional support for our moms and also connect with resources for other needs they may have.”

Erin Backus, Black MamasATX Grant Manager. Photo credit: Erin Backus

 

Castelli said she didn’t have worries before her pregnancy, but this changed as she got closer to her due date and after the ill-treatment, she received at her hospital. However, on her due date, Castelli was grateful for her home birth and unable to imagine herself at a hospital, which she always thought would be her plan.

“At hospitals, they tend to have you a little bit more isolated because they'll have IVs in you and different stuff,” Castelli said. “They want to have the Doppler and stuff on your stomach, and you know, you got to get in that gown and stuff. At home, I didn't have on no clothes but my bra, like I got to be completely free. I got to move around and like it was perfect. I mean, it was hard, but it was perfect.”

Castelli gave birth to her healthy baby boy in June 2021 in the comfort of her living room with the help of her husband, her midwife and doula. Castelli now recommends home births to any mother who, like her, is at higher risk of dying during pregnancy simply because of race.

“Just as a society we want to avoid it, but we cannot avoid the numbers and we cannot avoid the fact that women of color are way, way, I don't even know the numbers but we’re way more safe to be at home than we are in hospital,” Castelli said.

Castelli has enjoyed being a new mother and is expecting her second child, who she is planning to have another home birth for. Castelli will use the same birthing team she used during her first pregnancy. 

“I feel like motherhood is something that I always wanted,” Castelli said.” I always wanted to have like little humans around and, you know, give my contribution to society, and put out some good humans. But it's tough, but I will say having a birthing team that is super hands-on even postpartum has been amazing.”

The overall goal for Black Mamas ATX, Blackhomebirths Matter ATX and many similar organizations such as Giving Austin Labor Support(GALS), Mama Sana Vibrant Woman and Healing Hands Community Doula Project is to assure that Black women can for once not worry about a moment in their lives that is supposed to be enjoyed and not a possible death.

“A lot of people, you know, it’s their first time being pregnant,” Backus said. “They've seen the statistics, they've seen, you know, what's going on with celebrities and they just have a lot of questions. They have a lot of fears, and our doulas do a great job of supporting and giving them information.”

The Castelli family, Alexis Castelli, and Dedrick Castelli pose for the picture while holding their son, Zakari Armstrong, Sunday, April 24 at Pflugerville lake park located at 18216 Weiss Ln, Pflugerville, TX. Photo credit: Timia Cobb